As the title says, I think that Dave Chappelle’s ideas regarding transgender issues are archaic. He is no longer the 20 year-old superstar renegade going against the against an unfair system. He’s almost in his 50’s now, a well respected staple in the comedy scene who has seen and experienced a lot of bullshit.
His latest comedy special, The Closer, reflects this. As the last in a series of Netflix specials, Chappelle returns to old stomping grounds, primarily with Trans issues. As a comedy special, it is certainly his weakest. I thought a lot of the jokes were decent but they are not Chappelle at his best. His energy is somewhat tired, I would even say exhausted.
Yet, I think that The Closer is more interesting as a portrait of a man who is reflecting on his time trying to navigate these issues and being honest in a way that I can appreciate. Is it the best rhetorical argument he has ever made? No, but I have found that true honesty hardly ever is. This is a person who has done the soap box debating in the past. With his comedy, he has been able to interrogate issues with humor and grace.
In contrast, The Closer is messy and complicated, just like his feelings. If anything, his harshest critics are the same. I’m not here to tell you that their feelings aren’t justified. I’m a straight Asian man. In the supposed conflict between Chappelle’s championing of blacks and comedians versus the LGBTQ warriors fighting for their rights, I am at best a supporter of both and at the very least someone who walked into a bar in the middle of a drunk fight before I have had my first drink.
Twitter is going off right now, calling Chappelle transphobic and disingenuous. I’m not sure if I agree with either of those statements. Chappelle has never been one to hate on any group just for existing. This is a man who lives in the middle of honky-tonk Ohio, full of white people as a black man who knows his history. Even with his jokes that supposedly put down trans people, it is easy to see that in a fit of emotion people forget that he has made jokes about everyone of every category. Whites, blacks, asians, gays, men, women, rich, poor, and everything outside and inbetween.
I think his frustrations come more from when people band together and act as a digital tribal unit. With the internet, these voices become a force, sucking out the individuality and nuance that come from constructive conversation. Whether we like to admit it or not, our ability to tribalize gives us a sonic and psychic power that can make it impossible to find the humanity of it all.
In terms of the accusations of him being disingenuous, I would say that is one thing Dave Chappelle has never been in his standup. Many people are pointing to the fact that he might be baiting people for attention. Maybe that is true. After all, he is a businessman now, no longer a naive kid but a stone-cold player who has cut up his niche kingdom in the entertainment world, playing the game on his own terms.
Some people say that his story about trans comedian, Daphne Dorman, is nothing but a shield. They say that telling this story reveals Chappelle’s true nature as a phobic conman trying to hide his hatred and bolster his own position.
Yet, I felt the exact opposite. His anger at the death of his friend and the tears that wet his eyes told me otherwise. To me, this is a desperate rant of a man who is tired of the psychic powers that reduce the humanity of any group and the mental and physical casualties from those that have been caught in the warpaths.
Again, I don’t agree with Chappelle on trans issues. He stated that “gender is a fact.” It isn’t. Biological sex is a fact. Sexual identity and orientation is a truth that goes beyond anything that can be explained by material means. Science is trying to figure out the neuro-science behind these things, but I am not going to pretend I am some expert.
There are many people in the Black LGBTQ community who are also speaking out about these issues. They believe that Chappelle’s dialogue doesn’t include them in the discussion, despite being an intersection of the two communities. Again, I think Chappelle’s age is showing here.
But what do I know? I’m just the guy on the sidelines of all of this, right? What I do know is that trans people know in their hearts who they are, just like I know in mine that we all deserve a chance at happiness.
Chappelle knows this, too. He has already declared what he plans to say to Daphne’s child when they grow up:
“Son, I knew your father and he was a beautiful woman.”
Like most jokes, Chappelle infuses this line with his honesty. With this line, he acknowledges both his personal beliefs while acknowledging Daphne’s truth. Some might say he didn’t do enough and in some ways I don’t think so, either. Yet, these two people, despite supposedly being on opposite sides, had a real human friendship and acknowledged the beauty in each other.
Chappelle says in The Closer that people weren’t listening to him. I think it goes both ways. Both sides have run out of logic and are fighting a spiritual war with all they have left: humanity. That humanity can be both beautiful and ugly but right now, all I see is shrapnel.
Maybe the saddest truth is that despite Chappelle addressing the LGBTQ community directly at the end of The Closer, it might have hit hardest with people like me. The people on the sidelines of the bar fight who are just trying to enjoy our drinks without spilling our own cups from the rough and tumble. I’m not angry, indifferent, or even a troll looking to egg things further. I’m just sad. Like Chappelle, I just want us all to laugh again.
After writing this piece, I saw this youtube video that really helps further contextualize my thoughts and even taught me alot about trans issues. It’s a bit long but highly informative. The youtuber is a trans woman that explains all of the nuance better than I ever could. I hope you take the time to check it out.